The Dead Sea Scrolls were discovered in 11 caves between 1947 and 1956
on the northwest shore of the Dead Sea.
1 Based on the
science of paleography, "...a few of the scrolls would date from the
second century B.C.E., the vast majority from the first century B.C.E.,
and a smaller number from the first century C.E." This dating also
has been verified by carbon-14 analysis. Some of the scrolls
contain specific references to people who lived during this period,
giving further evidence of the dating. In addition, artifacts in
and around the caves support this same dating. Thus, several lines
of evidence confirm the dating of these documents from a period of 200
B.C.-100 AD.
2
It is generally agreed that the sect that possessed the biblical
documents and who wrote many of the non-biblical documents are the
Essenes. However, there are other minority opinions. The
founder of the sect that possessed the Dead Sea Scrolls is called the
"Teacher of Righteousness." Wise, et. al., have been able to write
a composite of the "Teacher of Righteousness" as follows:
The Teacher of Righteousness was a priest exceptionally gifted in
religious insight; indeed, had been granted special revelations from God
about the true meaning of Scripture and the proper interpretation of the
Law of Moses. Although he succeeded in gaining a following among
other priests and righteous Jews, he was opposed by the Man of the Lie,
who by his cunning rhetoric was able to dissuade many from submitting to
the Teacher's precepts. The Flattery-Seekers also opposed the
ministry of the Teacher. The Wicked Priest, however, initially
seemed to be favorable to the Teacher; but "when he ruled in Israel" he showed himself
to be irreligious, greedy, corrupt, and violent. He harried the
Teacher and his followers, drove them into exile, and on at least one
occasion made an attempt to have the Teacher killed--apparently without
success. The Wicked Priest was threatened by Gentile powers and
was captured and mistreated by them. There is no certain
indication that the Teacher died a violent death, although that is
possible.3
There has arisen considerable controversy about the identity of
the "Teacher of Righteousness." Some say he as a person,
and some say this was a title of an office held among the
Essenes. Some clam the "Teacher of Righteousness" was a
messiah and was crucified, and say the Teacher must have been
Jesus. However, this latter claim is highly unlikely.
The reference to crucifixion is in
A Commentary on Nahum,
4Q169. Alexander Jannaeus ruled as King of Israel and high
priest from 103-76 BC. Jannaeus was severe with those he
regarded as enemies, and executed 800 of them by crucifixion.
This is shown in fragment 3-4, Col. 1
4. But
there is no evident that the Teacher of Righteousness died by
crucifixion.
To further show that there is no evident that the "Teacher of
Righteousness" was Jesus, Kerry A. Shirts, summarizing Dupon-Sommer,
lists the
differences between the "Teacher of Righteousness" and Jesus as follows:
- The Teacher of Righteousness was a priest, as son of Levi;
Jesus was not a priest, but "son of David."
- The Teacher of Righteousness was described as "Messiah
of Aaron and Israel"; Jesus was called "the Messiah."
- The Teacher of Righteousness probably lived generally in
Judaea; Jesus was a Galilean and his preaching took place
principally on the shores of the Lake of Tiberius.
- The Teacher of Righteousness was a learned master,
venerated to the point his followers would not pronounce his
name; Jesus was a familiar teacher, whom his disciples and
multitudes approached with complete freedom, whose name was
neither secret nor mysterious.
- The Teacher of Righteousness was an author; Jesus wrote
nothing, but only spoke his sermons.
- The most serious difference is that they were separated
by a century. The Teacher of Righteousness died in
65-63 B.C. under the Jewish Priest Aristobulus II; Jesus
died 30 A.D. under the Roman procurator Pontius Pilate.5
Now recall that
Fields made this statement:
We now know that the Jesus myth of the New Testament was taken from
the story of the founder of the Essene cult. The founder of the Essenes
was named Jesus, he was crucified in 88 B.C.E. and everything good that
Jesus of Nazareth is said to have said was written almost a hundred
years before Jesus of Nazareth is said to have lived.6
There does not appear to be anything verifiable in this statement.
Fields appears to be gravely mistaken.
In order to be as thorough as possible to understand Fields'
arguments and supporting references, I additionally explored all Dead
Seas Scrolls that were cross-referenced by Wise, et. al., for passages
in the New Testament.
7
Some of these are remarkable and very interesting. However,
none of these cross referenced the passion
of Christ, or specifically, his crucifixion. The following table
summarizes all of Wise, et. al., cross references for the gospels,
showing in the last column the Dead Seas Scroll document:
| Matthew |
5:3-10 |
4Q525 2 ii |
| Matthew |
6:33 |
4Q417 1 i 17-28 |
| Matthew |
7:27 |
4Q424 1 2-4 |
| Matthew |
11:2-5 |
4Q521 2+4 ii 4-14 |
| Matthew |
22:30-32 |
4Q521 7+5 ii |
| Mark |
4:39-41 |
4Q541 7 |
| Luke |
1:32-33 |
4Q246 1:9-2:3 |
| Luke |
2:32, 34 |
4Q541 9 i 2-7 |
| Luke |
7:22 |
4Q521 2+4 ii 4-14 |
| John |
8:12 |
4Q541 24 |
Fields also made stated this about the Dead Seas Scrolls:
These old scrolls simply destroy the credibility of the
historical foundations of Christianity by proving the New Testament
evolved from the uninspired, historical, writings of man.6
This is an unfounded and incredible statement. You see above
what are the evidences, and these certainly do NOT suggest the
conclusions that Fields has made. The book by Wise, et. al, is
likely available in your public library and you can certainly purchase
it at
www.amazon.com. In
addition, from the previous page I showed that the historicity of Jesus
is beyond question.
I do hope to adequately show on this webpage that there was indeed a
preceding document that foretold in amazing accuracy the entirety of the
life of Jesus Christ. That document is the Old Testament. It
is not the non-biblical document in the Dead Seas Scrolls.